On the Mysteries 9
Latin text: Migne, PL 16 (Latin text: Migne, Patrologia Latina, digitized by Open Greek and Latin (patrologia_latina-dev, University of Leipzig), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0). Compare: Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, series 2, vol. 10 (1896).
Chapter 9
9PL 16:405b–409a
Forte dicas: Aliud video, quomodo tu mihi asseris quod Christi corpus accipiam? Et hoc nobis adhuc superest ut probemus. Quantis igitur utimur exemplis! Probemus non hoc esse quod natura for mavit, sed quod benedictio consecravit: majoremque vim esse benedictionis quam naturae; quia benedic tione etiam natura ipsa mutatur. Virgam tenebat Moyses, projecit eam, et facta est serpens. Rursus prehendit cau dam serpentis, et in virgæ naturam revertit. Vides igitur prophetica gratia bis mutatam esse naturam et serpentis et virgæ? Currebant Ægypti flumina puro aquarum meatu, subito de fontium venis sanguis coepit erumpere; et non erat potus in fluviis (Exod. VII, 20 et seq.). Rursus prophetae prece cruor cessa vit fluminum, aquarum natura remeavit. Circumclu sus undique erat populus Hebraeorum, hinc Ægyptiis vallatus, inde mari clausus: virgam levavit Moyses, separavit se aqua, et in murorum specie congelavit, atque inter undas via pedestris apparuit. Jordanis retrorsum conversus contra na turam in sui fontis revertit exordium. Nonne claret naturam vel maritimorum fluctuum vel fluvialis cursus esse mutatam? Sitiebat populus pa trum, tetigit Moyses petram, et aqua de petra fluxit. Numquid non praeter naturam operata est gratia, ut aquam vomeret petra, quam non habebat natura? Merrha fluvius amarissimus erat, ut sitiens populus bibere non posset. Misit Moyses lignum in aquam, et amaritudinem suam aquarum natura deposuit, quam infusa subito gratia temperavit. Sub Elisaeo propheta uni ex filiis prophe tarum excussum est ferrum de securi, et statim mer sum est. Rogavit Elisaeum, qui amiserat ferrum: misit etiam Elisæus lignum in aquam, et ferrum na tavit ( IV Reg. VI, 6). Utique et hoc praeter naturam factum cognoscimus; gravior est enim ferri species, quam aquarum liquor. Advertimus igitur majoris esse virtutis gra tiam quam naturam, et adhuc tamen prophetica benedictionis numeramus gratiam? Quod si tantum valuit humana benedictio, ut naturam converteret; quid dicimus de ipsa conse cratione divina, ubi verba ipsa Domini Salvatoris operantur? Nam sacramentum istud quod accipis, Christi sermone conficitur. Quod si tantum valuit sermo Eliæ, ut ignem de coelo deponeret: non va lebit Christi sermo, ut species mutet elementorum? De totius mundi operibus legisti: Quia ipse dixit, et facta sunt: ipse mandavit, et creata sunt (Psal. CXLVIII, 5); sermo ergo Christi qui potuit ex nihilo facere quod non erat, non potest ea quae sunt, in id mutare, quod non erant? Non enim minus est novas rebus dare, quam mutare naturas. Sed quid argumentis utimur? Suis utamur exemplis, incarnationisque exemplo astruamus mys terii veritatem. Numquid naturæ usus praecessit, cum Jesus Dominus ex Maria nasceretur? Si ordi nem quaerimus, viro mixta femina generare consue vit. Liquet igitur quod præter naturae ordinem Virgo generavit. Et hoc quod conficimus corpus, ex Vir gine est: quid hic quaeris naturæ ordinem in Christi corpore, cum praeter naturam sit ipse Dominus Jesus partus ex Virgine? Vera utique caro Christi, quae crucifixa est, quæ sepulta est: vere ergo carnis il lius sacramentum est. Ipse clamat Dominus Jesus: Hoc est corpus meum ( Matth, XXVI, 26). Ante benedictionem ver borum coelestium alia species nominatur, post con secrationem corpus significatur. Ipse dicit sanguinem suum. Ante consecrationem aliud dicitur, post consecra tionem sanguis nuncupatur. Et tu dicis: Amen, hoc est, verum est. Quod os loquitur, mens interna fateatur: quod sermo sonat, affectus sentiat. His igitur sacramentis pascit Ecclesiam suam Christus, quibus animae firmatur substantia: meri toque videns profectum ejus gratiae continentem, di cit ad eam: Quam decora facta sunt ubera tua, soror mea sponsa! Quam decora facta sunt a vino: et odor ves timentorum tuorum super omnia aromata! Favus di stillans labia tua, o sponsa, mel et lac sub lingua tua, et odor vestimentorum tuorum sicut odor Libani. Hortus con clusus, soror mea sponsa, hortus conclusus, fons signatus (Cant. iv, i0 et seq.), Quo significat signatum debere apud te manere mysterium, ne violetur operibus malae vitae, atque adulterio castitatis, ne divulgetur quibus non convenit, ne garrula loquacitate dispergatur in perfidos. Bona ergo debet esse fidei tuæ custodia, ut intemerata vitae ac silentii integritas perseveret. Unde et Ecclesia altitudinem servans myste riorum coelestium, rejicit a se graviores venti pro cellas, et invitat vernantis gratiae suavitatem: et sciens quod hortus suus Christo displicere non pos sit, ipsum advocat Sponsum dicens: Exsurge aquilo, et veni auster: perfla hortum meum, et defluant un guenta mea. Descendat frater meus in hortum suum, et edat fructum pomiferarum sua rum. Bonas enim arbores et fructiferas habet, quae radices suas linxerint sacri fontis irri guo, et in bonos fructus novae fecunditatis germine pullulaverint; ut non jam prophetica caedantur secu ri, sed Evangelica ubertate fecundentur. Denique fertilitate earum etiam Dominus de lectatus respondet: Ingressus sum in hortum meum, soror mea Sponsa: vindemiavi myrrham meam cum un guentis meis, manducavi cibum meum cum melle meo, bibi potum meum cum lacte meo. Quare cibum et potum dixerit, fidelis intellige. Illud au tem non dubium, quod in nobis ipse mandu cat et bibit, sicut in nobis legisti quia in carcere esse se dicit. Unde et Ecclesia videns tantam gratiam, hortatur filios suos, hortatur proximos, ut ad sa cramenta concurrant, dicens: Edite proximi mei, et bibite, et inebriamini, fratres mei. Quid edamus, quid bibamus, alibi tibi per Prophetam Spiritus sanctus expressit dicens: Gustate et videte quoniam suavis est Dominus: beatus vir qui sperat in eo. In illo sacramento Christus est; quia cor pus est Christi: non ergo corporalis esca, sed spi ritalis est. Unde et Apostolus de typo ejus ait: Quia patres nostri escam spiritalem manducaverunt, et po tum spiritalem biberunt; corpus enim Dei corpus est spiritale: corpus Christi corpus est divini Spiritus; quia Spiritus Christus, ut legi mus: Spiritus ante faciem nostram Christus Dominus ( Thren. IV, 20). Et in Petri Epistola habemus: Christus pro nobis mortuus est (I Pet. n, 24). Deni que cor nostrum esca ista confirmat, et potus iste laetificat cor hominis, ut Propheta memoravit (Psal. CIII, i5). Unde adepti omnia, sciamus regeneratos nos esse: nec dicamus, quomodo regenerati sumus? Numquid in ventrem matris nostræ introivimus, et renati sumus? non agnosco usum naturæ. Sed nullus hic naturæ ordo, ubi excellentia gratiæ est. De nique non semper usus naturæ generationem fa cit: generatum ex Virgine Christum Dominum con fitemur, et naturae ordinem denegamus. Non enim ex viro Maria concepit: sed de Spiritu sancto in utero accepit, ut dicit Matthaeus: Quia inventa est in utero habens de Spiritu sancto ( Matth. I, 48). Si ergo superveniens Spiritus sanctus in Virginem, con ceptionem operatus est, et generationis munus implevit: non utique dubitandum est quod superveniens in fontem, vel super eos qui baptismum consequun tur, veritatem regenerationis operetur.
Perhaps you say: “I see something else; how do you assure me that I receive the body of Christ?” This, too, remains for us to prove. How many examples, then, we use! Let us prove that this is not what nature formed but what the blessing consecrated, and that the power of blessing is greater than that of nature; because by blessing nature itself is changed. Moses held a rod; he threw it down, and it became a serpent. Again he took hold of the serpent’s tail, and it returned to the nature of a rod. Do you see, then, that by prophetic grace the nature both of the serpent and of the rod was twice changed? The rivers of Egypt were running with a pure flow of waters; suddenly blood began to burst from the veins of the springs, and there was no drink in the rivers. Again, at the prophet’s prayer, the blood of the rivers ceased and the nature of the waters returned. The people of the Hebrews were hemmed in on every side, walled in on one side by the Egyptians, shut in on the other by the sea; Moses raised his rod, the water separated and stood frozen like walls, and a path on foot appeared between the waves. The Jordan, turned back against nature, returned to the source of its spring. Is it not plain that the nature both of the sea’s waves and of the river’s course was changed? The people of the fathers were thirsty; Moses touched the rock, and water flowed from the rock. Did not grace work beyond nature, that the rock poured out water which by nature it did not have? Marah was a most bitter river, so that the thirsty people could not drink. Moses threw wood into the water, and the nature of the waters put off its bitterness, which grace, suddenly poured in, tempered. Under the prophet Elisha the iron of an axe flew off from one of the sons of the prophets and at once sank. He who had lost the iron asked Elisha; Elisha too threw wood into the water, and the iron floated. Certainly we know that this too was done beyond nature; for the substance of iron is heavier than the liquid of the waters. We notice, then, that grace is of greater power than nature; and yet we are still counting the grace of a prophet’s blessing. But if a human blessing had such power as to change nature, what do we say of the divine consecration itself, where the very words of the Lord and Saviour work? For this sacrament which you receive is made by the word of Christ. And if the word of Elijah had such power as to bring down fire from heaven, will not the word of Christ have power to change the kinds of the elements? You have read of the works of the whole world: “For he spoke, and they were made; he commanded, and they were created.” The word of Christ, then, which could make out of nothing what was not, can it not change things that are into what they were not? For it is no less to give things new natures than to change natures. But why do we use arguments? Let us use his own examples, and by the example of the incarnation establish the truth of the mystery. Did the course of nature come first when the Lord Jesus was born of Mary? If we look for the order, a woman joined with a man usually conceives. It is plain, then, that the Virgin conceived beyond the order of nature. And this body which we make is from the Virgin: why do you look here for the order of nature in the body of Christ, when the Lord Jesus himself was born of a virgin beyond nature? It was the true flesh of Christ which was crucified, which was buried; truly, then, it is the sacrament of that flesh. The Lord Jesus himself cries out: “This is my body.” Before the blessing of the heavenly words another kind is named; after the consecration the body is signified. He himself calls it his blood. Before the consecration it is called something else; after the consecration it is named blood. And you say: Amen, that is, it is true. What the mouth speaks, let the mind within confess; what the word sounds, let the heart feel. With these sacraments, then, Christ feeds his Church, by which the substance of the soul is made firm; and rightly, seeing its continual advance in grace, he says to her: “How comely your breasts have become, my sister, my bride! How comely they have become from wine, and the odour of your garments above all spices! Your lips distil a honeycomb, O bride, honey and milk are under your tongue, and the odour of your garments is like the odour of Lebanon. A garden enclosed is my sister, my bride, a garden enclosed, a fountain sealed.” By which he signifies that the mystery ought to remain sealed with you, that it be not violated by the works of an evil life and by the adultery of chastity, that it be not divulged to those to whom it is not fitting, that it be not scattered among the faithless by chattering talkativeness. Your guarding of faith, then, ought to be good, so that the integrity of life and silence may continue undefiled. Hence the Church too, keeping the depth of the heavenly mysteries, drives away from herself the more violent storms of wind and invites the sweetness of springing grace; and knowing that her garden cannot displease Christ, she calls the Bridegroom himself, saying: “Arise, north wind, and come, south wind; blow through my garden, and let my ointments flow down. Let my brother come down into his garden and eat the fruit of his apple trees.” For she has good and fruitful trees, which have dipped their roots in the watering of the sacred font and have sprouted with the bud of new fruitfulness into good fruits; so that they are no longer cut down by the prophetic axe but made fruitful by the plenty of the Gospel. Indeed the Lord too, delighted by their fertility, answers: “I have come into my garden, my sister, my bride; I have gathered my myrrh with my spices; I have eaten my food with my honey; I have drunk my drink with my milk.” Why he said food and drink, understand, you who are faithful. But this is not doubtful, that he himself eats and drinks in us, just as you have read that he says he is in prison in us. Hence the Church too, seeing so great a grace, exhorts her sons, exhorts her neighbours, to run together to the sacraments, saying: “Eat, my neighbours, and drink, and be inebriated, my brothers.” What we should eat and what we should drink the Holy Spirit has expressed to you elsewhere through the Prophet, saying: “Taste and see that the Lord is sweet; blessed is the man who hopes in him.” In that sacrament is Christ, because it is the body of Christ: it is not, then, bodily food but spiritual. Hence the Apostle too says of its type: “Our fathers ate spiritual food and drank spiritual drink”; for the body of God is a spiritual body; the body of Christ is the body of a divine Spirit, because Christ is Spirit, as we read: “The Spirit before our face is Christ the Lord.” And in the Epistle of Peter we have: “Christ died for us.” Indeed this food strengthens our heart, and this drink gladdens the heart of man, as the Prophet recalled. Having obtained all things, then, let us know that we have been regenerated; and let us not say, “How have we been regenerated? Did we enter into our mother’s womb and were born again? I do not recognize the course of nature.” But there is no order of nature here, where there is the excellence of grace. Indeed the course of nature does not always bring about generation: we confess that Christ the Lord was born of a virgin, and we deny the order of nature. For Mary did not conceive of a man, but received in her womb of the Holy Spirit, as Matthew says: “For she was found with child of the Holy Spirit.” If, then, the Holy Spirit coming upon the Virgin brought about the conception and fulfilled the work of generation, it is certainly not to be doubted that, coming upon the font or upon those who obtain baptism, he brings about the truth of regeneration.
Exod 4:3 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 4:4 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 7:20 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 7:21 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 14:21 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 14:22 (allusion, high confidence) · Josh 3:16 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 114:3 (113:3 LXX) (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 17:6 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 15:25 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 6:5 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 6:6 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Kgs 18:38 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 148:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 1:34 (allusion, medium confidence) · Matt 26:26 (quotation, high confidence) · Song 4:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Song 4:11 (quotation, high confidence) · Song 4:12 (quotation, high confidence) · Song 4:16 (quotation, high confidence) · Song 5:1 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 25:36 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 34:8 (33:9 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 10:3 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 10:4 (quotation, high confidence) · Lam 4:20 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Pet 2:21 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 104:15 (103:15 LXX) (allusion, high confidence) · John 3:4 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 1:18 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Ambrose argues from the miracles of Scripture and from the virgin birth that the word of Christ changes the bread and wine into his body and blood, which feed the Church, and that the Spirit truly regenerates in baptism.
- Ambrose’s teaching on the consecration (“this sacrament… is made by the word of Christ”; “before the consecration… after the consecration”) is translated as written. The digital text inserts references to Gratian’s Decretum, added by later editors; they are removed.
- Exod 4:3–4; 7:20–21; 14:21–22; Josh 3:16; Ps 114:3 (LXX 113:3); Exod 17:6; 15:23–25; 2 Kgs 6:5–6; 1 Kgs 18:38; Ps 148:5; Matt 26:26; Song 4:10–12, 16; 5:1; Matt 25:36; Ps 34:8 (LXX 33:9); 1 Cor 10:3–4; Lam 4:20; 1 Pet 2:21; Ps 104:15 (LXX 103:15); John 3:4; Matt 1:18.
Notes on the original text
- Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slips; OCR slips and inline footnote letter; a later editor's reference to Gratian's Decretum; a later editor's reference to Gratian's Decretum, and page number; inline footnote letter; inline footnote letter and OCR slip; inline footnote letters; page number; page number and stray marks; stray mark; words run together): Forie dicas → Forte dicas; nsseris → asseris; non boc esse → non hoc esse; tione eliam → tione etiam; piojecit eam, et facta estserpens → projecit eam, et facta est serpens; erumpere;et non erat potus in fluviis(£xod. → erumpere; et non erat potus in fluviis (Exod.; seq.). a Rursus a prophetae → seq.). Rursus prophetae; remeavit, Circumclu → remeavit. Circumclu; et nqua de petra → et aqua de petra; natura? b Merrha → natura? Merrha; Moyses 319 lignum in a-. quam → Moyses lignum in aquam; depo. suit → deposuit; Suh Elisaeo → Sub Elisaeo; enim c ferri species → enim ferri species; majoris esse d virtutis → majoris esse virtutis; ipsa " conse → ipsa conse; non VI lebit → non va lebit; elementorum'I De → elementorum? De; (Psal. CXLVIII, 5. De Consec., dist. 2 I c. In quibus, § Cu jus clare); sermo → (Psal. CXLVIII, 5); sermo; erant? a Non enim → erant? Non enim; astruamus mys teri: veritatem → astruamus mys terii veritatem; conflcimus → conficimus; carnis it lius → carnis il lius; Hoc eat corpus → Hoc est corpus; coelestium b alia species nominatur, nost con → coelestium alia species nominatur, post con; significatur (De Consec. dist. dO, § Hæc et hit). Ipse dicit sanguinem 340 suum → significatur. Ipse dicit sanguinem suum; nuncupatur. c Et tu dicis → nuncupatur. Et tu dicis; facta.unt ubera tua, Moror mea sponsa! Quam decora facta aunt a vino → facta sunt ubera tua, soror mea sponsa! Quam decora facta sunt a vino; tuper omnia aromata! d Favut di → super omnia aromata! Favus di; sicutodor → sicut odor; Adei tuæ → fidei tuæ; veni autter → veni auster; edat e fructum → edat fructum; Ingressu, sum → Ingressus sum; meis, f manducavi → meis, manducavi; nobis 341 ipse mandu → nobis ipse mandu; hortatur lilios suos → hortatur filios suos; In illo sacramento (De Consec. dial. 2, cap.; lie illo sacram.Christus est → In illo sacramento Christus est; spiritale: corpus Christi corpus est divini Spiritus; a quia → spiritale: corpus Christi corpus est divini Spiritus; quia; Chri'tu. Dominus → Christus Dominus; mortuus eat (I Pet. → mortuus est (I Pet.; potus iste 342 laetificat → potus iste laetificat; naluræ ordo → naturæ ordo; naturæ b generationem → naturæ generationem; Spiritu sanct, in utero → Spiritu sancto in utero; inventa eat in utero → inventa est in utero; imple. vit → implevit.
Topics: Eucharist, Baptism, Christology
Cite (SBL): Ambrose, Myst. 9 (PL 16:405b–409a; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/ambrose-mysteriis/9/#p-9). (abbreviation not yet checked)
BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-ambrose-mysteriis-9) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 16 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged), then compared section by section with the public-domain English of NPNF² 10 (de Romestin, 1896); differences checked against the Latin.