Literal Commentary on Genesis 12.36–12.37

Latin text: Zycha, CSEL 28.1 (Latin text: Joseph Zycha, De Genesi ad litteram (CSEL 28.1, 1894), digitized by Open Greek and Latin (csel-dev, University of Leipzig), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).

Show

Chapter 12

12.36CSEL 28.1:433–434

Nimirum enim erunt et tunc ista tria genera uisionum, sed nulla falsitate pro alio aliud adprobabitur nec in corporalibus nec in spiritalibus uisis, multo minus in intellectualibus, quibus ita praesentatis et perspicuis perfruetur, ut longe minore euidentia nunc nobis adiaceant istae species corporales, quas sensu carnis adtingimus et eis multi ita sunt dediti, ut solas esse arbitrentur et, quidquid tale non est, putent omnino non esse. sapientes autem ita sunt in his corporalibus uisis, ut, quamuis ea praesentiora uideantur, certiores sint tamen in illis, quae praeter corporis speciem praeterque corporis similitudinem intellegendo utcumque praespiciunt, quamuis ea non ualeant ita mente conspicere, ut haec sensu corporis intuentur. sancti uero angeli et his corporalibus iudicandis atque administrandis praesunt nec eis tamquam praesentioribus familiaribus inclinantur et eorum significatiuas similitudines in spiritu ita discernunt et tanta potentia quodammodo tractant, ut eas possint etiam hominum spiritibus reuelando miscere, et illam incommutabilem substantiam creatoris ita conspiciunt, ut uisione atque amore et eam praeponant omnibus et secundum eam iudicent de omnibus et in eam dirigantur, ut agantur, et ex ea dirigant quidquid agunt. denique quamuis abrepto apostolo a carnis sensibus in tertium caelum et paradisum hoc ipsum certe defuit ad plenam perfectamque cognitionem rerum, quae angelis inest, quod, siue in corpore siue extra corpus esset, nesciebat. hoc utique non deerit, cum receptis corporibus in resurrectione mortuorum corruptibile hoc induetur incorruptione et mortale hoc induetur inmortalitate. omnia enim euidentia erunt sine ulla falsitate, sine ulla ignorantia suis ordinibus distributa, et corporalia et spiritalia et intellectualia, in natura integra et beatitate perfecta.

For then too, surely, there will be these three kinds of vision, but by no falsity will one thing be approved for another, neither in bodily sights nor in spiritual ones, much less in intellectual ones, which the soul will enjoy so present and clear that, compared with them, these bodily forms which we touch with the sense of the flesh lie before us now with far less evidence; yet many are so given over to them that they suppose they alone exist and think that whatever is not of that kind does not exist at all. The wise, however, are so placed among these bodily sights that, although these seem more present, they are nevertheless more certain about the things which, apart from bodily form and apart from the likeness of a body, they foresee in some way by understanding, though they cannot behold them with the mind as they look at these with the sense of the body. But the holy angels both preside over judging and governing these bodily things and are not bent toward them as toward more present and familiar things; and they discern their signifying likenesses in the spirit and handle them, in a way, with such power that they can even mingle them with the spirits of human beings by revealing; and they so behold that unchangeable substance of the Creator that by vision and love they prefer it to all things, judge all things according to it, and are directed toward it to be moved, and from it direct whatever they do. Finally, even though the apostle was snatched from the senses of the flesh into the third heaven and paradise, this certainly was lacking to him for that full and perfect knowledge of things which is in the angels: that he did not know whether he was in the body or out of the body. This will certainly not be lacking when, the bodies received back in the resurrection of the dead, this corruptible shall put on incorruption and this mortal shall put on immortality. For all things will be evident, without any falsity, without any ignorance, arranged in their orders, the bodily and the spiritual and the intellectual, in a nature made whole and a happiness made perfect.

2 Cor 12:2–4 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 15:53 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: In the resurrection all three kinds of vision will remain, free of error; even Paul lacked the angels' full knowledge, which the saints will have when the mortal puts on immortality.

  • Texts: 2 Cor 12:2–4; 1 Cor 15:53.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (stray period inside the phrase): nec. in corporalibus → nec in corporalibus; quidquid. agunt → quidquid agunt.

Topics: Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Augustine, Gen. litt. 12.36 (CSEL 28.1:433–434; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/augustine-genesi-litteram/12-36/#p-12-36). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-augustine-genesi-litteram-12-36) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude (Opus) from the Latin of Zycha (CSEL 28.1, 1894); no public-domain English translation exists, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

12.37CSEL 28.1:434–435

Scio quidem nonnullos eorum, qui scripturas sanctas ante nos in fide catholica tractasse laudantur, etiam sic exposuisse, quod ait apostolus tertium caelum, ut corporalis et animalis et spiritalis hominis hic differentias accipi uellent atque ad illud incorporearum rerum genus excellenti euidentia contemplandum esse apostolum raptum: quod genus etiam in hac uita spiritales homines prae ceteris rebus diligunt eoque perfrui concupiscunt. ego autem cur maluerim spiritale et intellectuale dicere, quod illi fortasse animale et spiritale dixerunt, ut earundem rerum alia tantummodo nomina ponerem, iam in primis huius libri partibus me disseruisse suffecerit. quae si rite pro modulo nostro disputauimus, aut spiritalis lector haec adprobabit aut etiam, ut sit spiritalis, adiuuante spiritu sancto aliquid ex ista lectione proficiet. sed iam uniuersum hoc opus, quod duodecim uoluminibus continetur, isto tandem fine concludimus.

I know, indeed, that some of those who are praised for having treated the holy Scriptures before us in the catholic faith have also explained what the apostle calls the third heaven in such a way that they took it to mean the differences between the bodily, the animal, and the spiritual man, and held that the apostle was caught up to contemplate with excellent evidence that kind of incorporeal things which even in this life spiritual people love above all other things and long to enjoy. Why I preferred to say “spiritual” and “intellectual” where they perhaps said “animal” and “spiritual,” so that I would only be giving other names to the same things, it will suffice that I have discussed in the first parts of this book. If we have argued these things rightly, according to our small measure, either the spiritual reader will approve them, or, so that he may become spiritual, he will make some progress from this reading with the help of the Holy Spirit. But now at last we conclude with this ending this whole work, which is contained in twelve volumes.

1 Cor 2:14–15 (echo, medium confidence) · 2 Cor 12:2 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Augustine notes that earlier catholic interpreters read the third heaven as bodily, animal, and spiritual levels, explains that his terms differ only in name, and closes the twelve books.

  • The earlier interpreters are not named. The distinction of animal and spiritual man reflects 1 Cor 2:14–15.

Cite (SBL): Augustine, Gen. litt. 12.37 (CSEL 28.1:434–435; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/augustine-genesi-litteram/12-36/#p-12-37). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-augustine-genesi-litteram-12-37) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude (Opus) from the Latin of Zycha (CSEL 28.1, 1894); no public-domain English translation exists, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.