The Testimony of the Soul 1

Summary: Rather than appeal to pagan literature, which its readers do not trust, Tertullian calls the simple, untaught human soul itself as a witness to Christian truth.

Show

Latin text · CSEL 20:134–136

Magna curiositate et maiore longe memoria opus est ad studendum, si qui uelit ex litteris receptissimis quibusque philosophorum uel poetarum uel quorumlibet doctrinae ac sapientiae saecularis magistrorum testimonia excerpere Christianae ueritatis, ut aemuli persecutoresque eius de suo proprio instrumento et erroris in se et iniquitatis in nos rei reuincantur. nonnulli quidem, quibus de pristina litteratura et curiositatis labor et memoriae tenor perseuerauit, ad eum modum opuscula penes nos condiderunt: commemorantes et contestificantes in singula rationem et originem et traditionem et argumenta sententiarum, per quae recognosci possit nihil nos aut nouum aut portentosum suscepisse, de quo non etiam communes et publicae litterae ad suffragium nobis patrocinentur, si quid aut erroris eiecimus aut aequitatis admisimus. sed ne suis quidem magistris alias probatissimis atque lectissimis fidem inclinauit humana de incredulitate duritia, sicubi in argumenta Christianae defensionis impingunt. tunc uani poetae, cum deos humanis passionibus et fabulis designant, tunc philosophi duri, cum ueritatis fores pulsant. hactenus sapiens et prudens habebitur, qui prope Christianum pronuntiauerit, cum, si quid prudentiae aut sapientiae affectauerit seu caerimonias despuens seu saeculum reuincens pro Christiano denotetur. iam igitur nihil nobis erit cum litteris et doctrina peruersae felicitatis, cui in falso potius creditur quam in uero. uiderint, si qui de unico et solo deo pronuntiauerunt. immo nihil omnino relatum sit, quod agnoscat Christianus, ne exprobrare possit. nam et quod relatum est neque omnes sciunt neque qui sciunt constare confidunt. tanto abest, ut nostris litteris annuant homines, ad quas nemo uenit nisi iam Christianus. nouum testimonium aduoco, immo omni litteratura. notius, omni doctrina agitatius, omni editione uulgatius, toto homine maius id est totum quod est hominis. consiste in medio, anima; seu diuina et aeterna res es secundum plures philosophos, eo magis non mentieris: seu minime diuina, quoniam quidem mortalis, ut Epicuro soli uidetur, eo magis mentiri non debebis, seu de caelo exciperis seu de terra conciperis seu numeris seu atomis concinnaris seu cum corpore incipis seu post corpus induceris, undeunde et quoquo modo hominem facis animal rationale, sensus et scientiae capacissimum. sed non eam te aduoco, quae scholis formata, bybliothecis exercitata, academiis et porticibus Atticis pasta sapientiam ructas. te simplicem et rudem et impolitam et idioticam compello, qualem te habent qui te solam habent, illam ipsam de compito, de triuio, de textrino totam. imperitia tua mihi opus est, quoniam aliquantulae peritiae tuae nemo credit. ea expostulo quae tecum homini infers, quae aut ex temetipsa aut ex quocumque auctore tuo sentire didicisti. non es, quod sciam, Christiana. fieri enim, non nasci solet Christiana. tamen nunc a te testimonium flagitant Christiani, ab extranea aduersus tuos, ut uel tibi erubescant, quod nos ob ea oderint et inrideant, quae te nunc consciam detineant.

English · Claude translation

Great research and far greater memory are needed for the study, if anyone wishes to excerpt from the most accepted writings of the philosophers or poets or of any teachers of worldly learning and wisdom testimonies to the Christian truth, so that its rivals and persecutors may be convicted from their own proper documents, both of error toward themselves and of injustice toward us. Some indeed, in whom the labor of research and the retentiveness of memory from their former literary studies have persisted, have composed little works among us in this way: recording and attesting on each point the reasoning, origin, tradition, and arguments of the opinions, by which it may be recognized that we have taken up nothing either new or monstrous for which even common and public literature does not plead in our support, whether we have rejected some error or admitted some equity. But human hardness in unbelief has not inclined its trust even to its own teachers, otherwise most approved and most select, wherever they stumble into arguments for the Christian defense. Then the poets are foolish, when they portray the gods with human passions and fables; then the philosophers are harsh, when they knock at the doors of truth. A man will be held wise and prudent only so far as he has spoken almost as a Christian; whereas if he has affected any prudence or wisdom, whether by spitting on ceremonies or by convicting the world, he is branded as a Christian. Now, therefore, we will have nothing to do with the literature and teaching of a perverted happiness, which is believed rather in what is false than in what is true. Let them see to it, if some have spoken of the one and only God. Indeed, let nothing at all be reported that a Christian may recognize, lest he be able to reproach them with it. For even what has been reported not all know, and those who know are not confident that it is established. So far are people from assenting to our writings, to which no one comes unless he is already a Christian. I call a new witness, or rather one better known than all literature, more discussed than all teaching, more widespread than every publication, greater than the whole man: that is, the whole of what belongs to man. Stand in the midst, O soul. Whether you are a divine and eternal thing, as many philosophers hold, the less will you lie; or not divine at all, since you are mortal, as seems to Epicurus alone, the less ought you to lie; whether you are received from heaven or conceived from earth, whether you are composed of numbers or of atoms, whether you begin with the body or are introduced after the body, from wherever and in whatever manner, you make man a rational animal, most capable of perception and knowledge. But I do not call upon you as you are when, formed in the schools, trained in libraries, fed in the academies and porches of Athens, you belch out wisdom. I address you simple and rough and unpolished and untaught, such as they have you who have you alone, that very soul, all of you, from the crossroads, the street corner, the weaving shop. It is your inexperience I need, since no one believes your little bit of experience. I demand those things which you bring with you into man, which you have learned to perceive either from yourself or from your author, whoever he is. You are not, so far as I know, Christian; for a soul is accustomed to become Christian, not to be born so. Yet Christians now demand testimony from you, an outsider, against your own, so that they may be ashamed even before you, because they hate and mock us on account of those very things which now hold you as their accomplice.

About this passage

Source
CSEL 20:134–136 · August Reifferscheid and Georg Wissowa, eds., Quinti Septimi Florentis Tertulliani Opera, Pars 1, CSEL 20 (Prague: Tempsky; Vienna: Tempsky; Leipzig: Freytag, 1890), 134–143 · Latin text: August Reifferscheid and Georg Wissowa (CSEL 20), digitized by Open Greek and Latin, University of Leipzig (csel-dev), CC BY-SA 4.0
Text
As printed in CSEL 20. Manuscript variants and the editor's apparatus are not reproduced; no textual problem is noted in this passage.
Translation
Claude translation (claude-opus-5-5), 2026-09-27 · Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 20; made independently of existing English translations.
Compare
Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3 (1885) (an older public-domain English translation, whole volume at CCEL; checked against ours only after ours was made)

Notes

Translation notes

  • The digital text begins with the heading “IV. DE TESTIMONIO ANIMAE.”, which is removed here as not part of the text. It is heavily marred by doubled syllables (e.g. “excerperepere”), corrected below. “For a soul is accustomed to become Christian, not to be born so” echoes Tertullian's famous line in Apol. 18.4 (“fiunt, non nascuntur Christiani”).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (doubled letter in the digital text; doubled letters in the digital text; doubled syllable in the digital text; doubled syllables in the digital text; doubled word part in the digital text; dropped letter in the digital text; heading of the digital edition run into the text): IV. DE TESTIMONIO ANIMAE. Magna → Magna; excerperepere → excerpere; proprioio → proprio; fabuis → fabulis; pulsantsant → pulsant; pprope → prope; Christianono → Christiano; dodoctrina → doctrina; mementieriss → mentieris; capcapacissimum → capacissimum; bybliothecisis → bybliothecis; idioticamcam cocompello → idioticam compello; ChristiChristiana → Christiana.

Cite this passage

Tertullian, Test. 1 (trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/tertullian-testimonio/1/).

Plain text
Tertullian, Test. 1 (trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/tertullian-testimonio/1/).

Download citation:BibTeX ·RIS (Zotero, EndNote)

Whole work:BibTeX ·RIS ·Markdown text

Report an error in this passage