Instructions 1–1.31

Latin text: CSEL 15 (Latin text: B. Dombart (CSEL 15, 1887), digitized by Open Greek and Latin, University of Leipzig (csel-dev), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0). Compare: Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4 (1885).

Show

Chapter 1

1CSEL 15:3–5

LIBER PRIMVS. I. Praefatio. II. Indignatio Dei. III. Cultura daemonum. IIII. Saturnus. V. Iuppiter. VI. De fulmine ipsius Iouis <audita). VII. De septizonio et stellis. VIII. De sole et luna. VIIII. Mercurius. X. Neptunus. XI. Apollo sortilegus falsus. XII. Liber pater Bacchus. XIII. Inuictus. XIIII. Siluanus. XV. Hercules. XVI. De dis deabusque. XVII. De simulacris eorum. XVIII. De Ammudate et deo magno. XVIIII. Nemesiacis uanis. XX. Titanes. XXI. Montesianis. XXII. Hebetudo saeculi. XXIII. De ubique paratis. XXIIII. Inter utrumque uiuentibus. XXV. Qui timent et non credent. XXVI. Repugnantibus aduersus legem Christi (Dei uiui). XXVII. Stulte non permoreris Deo. XXVIII. Iusti resurgunt. XXVIIII. Diuiti incredulo malo. XXX. Diuites humiles estote. XXXI. Iudicibus. XXXII. Sibi placentibus. XXXIII. Gentilibus. XXXIIII. Item gentilibus ignaris. XXXV. De ligno uitae et mortis. XXXVI. De crucis stultitia. XXXVII. Qui iudaeidiant fanatici. XXXVIII. Iudaeis. XXXVIIII. Item Iudaeis. XL. Iterum ipsis. XLI. De Antechristi tempore.

Book One. 1. Preface. 2. The wrath of God. 3. The worship of demons. 4. Saturn. 5. Jupiter. 6. Hear about the thunderbolt of Jupiter himself. 7. On the Septizonium and the stars. 8. On the sun and the moon. 9. Mercury. 10. Neptune. 11. Apollo, the false soothsayer. 12. Father Liber, Bacchus. 13. The Unconquered. 14. Silvanus. 15. Hercules. 16. On the gods and goddesses. 17. On their images. 18. On Ammudates and the great god. 19. To the vain devotees of Nemesis. 20. The Titans. 21. To the Montesians. 22. The dullness of the age. 23. To those ready for anything. 24. To those who live between the two. 25. Those who fear and do not believe. 26. To those who resist the law of Christ (the living God). 27. Foolish one, you do not die to God. 28. The righteous rise again. 29. To the wicked unbelieving rich man. 30. You rich, be humble. 31. To judges. 32. To the self-satisfied. 33. To the Gentiles. 34. Again, to the ignorant Gentiles. 35. On the tree of life and of death. 36. On the folly of the cross. 37. Fanatics who judaize. 38. To the Jews. 39. Again, to the Jews. 40. Once more to them. 41. On the time of the Antichrist.

Notes and citation

Summary: The list of chapter titles of Book One of Commodian's Instructions.

  • Each chapter title is also the acrostic of its poem: the first letters of the lines spell the title.
  • Several titles are obscure: “Ammudates” (perhaps a Syrian god), the “Montesians,” and title 27 (“Stulte non permoreris Deo”) are translated literally.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (joined words): crucistultitia → crucis stultitia.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1 (CSEL 15:3–5; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.1CSEL 15:5–6

I. PRAEFATIO. Praefatio nostra uiam erranti demonstrat / Respectumque bonum, cum uenerit saeculi meta, / Aeternum fieri, quod discredunt inscia corda. / Ego similiter erraui tempore multo / Fana prosequendo parentibus insciis ipsis; / Abstuli me tandem inde legendo de lege. / Testifico Dominum: doleo pro ciuica turba, / Inscia quod pergit periens deos quaerere uanos; / Ob ea perdoctus ignaros instruo uerum.

Preface. Our preface shows the way to the one who wanders, and shows that a good reward will be eternal when the goal of this age comes — a thing ignorant hearts disbelieve. I too wandered for a long time, frequenting the temples, while my parents themselves were ignorant; at last I took myself away from there by reading in the law. I call the Lord to witness: I grieve for the crowd of my fellow citizens, because in ignorance it goes on, perishing, seeking vain gods. For this reason, now thoroughly taught, I instruct the ignorant in the truth.

Notes and citation

Summary: Commodian, himself converted from paganism by reading the law, announces that he will show the way to those who wander.

  • The acrostic spells PRAEFATIO (“Preface”). “The law” is the Old Testament Scriptures.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.1 (CSEL 15:5–6; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.2CSEL 15:6–7

II. INDIGNATIO DEI. In lege praecepit dominus caeli, terrae marisque: / Nolite, inquit, adorare deos inanes / De manibus uestris factos ex ligno uel auro, / Indignatio mea ne uos disperdat ob ista. / Gens ante, Moysi rudis, sine lege morata / Nesciensque Deum, defunctos reges orabant, / Ad quorum effigies faciebant idola uana. / Translatis Iudaeis Dominus de terra Aegypti / Inposuit legem postmodum et ista praecepit, / Omnipotenti sibi soli deseruire, non illis. / De resurrectione quoque docetur in ipsa / Et spe fortunata rursum in aeuo uiuendi, / Idola si uana relinquantur neque colantur.

The wrath of God. In the law the Lord of heaven, earth, and sea commanded: “Do not worship empty gods made by your hands out of wood or gold, lest my wrath destroy you for these things.” The nation before Moses, uncouth, living without law and not knowing God, prayed to dead kings and made vain idols after their likenesses. After the Lord had brought the Jews over from the land of Egypt, he then imposed the law and commanded this: that they serve him alone, the Almighty, and not those others. In the law also there is teaching about the resurrection and the happy hope of living again in the age to come, if vain idols are abandoned and not worshiped.

Exod 20:4 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 20:5 (allusion, medium confidence) · Lev 26:1 (allusion, medium confidence) · Deut 4:25 (allusion, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: God's law forbids the worship of idols, which began as prayers to dead kings, and promises resurrection to those who abandon them.

  • The acrostic spells INDIGNATIO DEI. The command is a free summary of Exod 20:3–5, Lev 26:1, and Deut 4:23–26.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.2 (CSEL 15:6–7; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.3CSEL 15:7–8

III. CVLTVRA DAEMONVM. Cum Deus / omnipotens exornasset mundi naturam, / Visitari uoluit terram ab angelis istam; / Legitima cuius spreuerunt illi dimissi; / Tanta fuit forma feminarum, quae flecteret illos. / Vt coinquinati non possunt caelo redire, / Rebelles ex illo contra Deum uerba misere. / Altissimus inde sententiam misit in illis; / De semine quorum Gigantes nati feruntur. / Ab ipsis in term artis prolatae fuere, / Et tingere lanas docuerunt et quaeque geruntur, / Mortales et illi mortuos simulacro ponebant. / Omnipotens autem, quod essent de semine prauo,. / Non censuit illos recipi defunctos e morte. / Vnde modo uagi subuertunt corpora multa; / Maxime quos hodie colitis et deos oratis.

The worship of demons. When God almighty had adorned the nature of the world, he willed that this earth be visited by angels; but, once sent down, they spurned his laws. So great was the beauty of women that it turned them aside. Since, defiled, they could not return to heaven, they became rebels and sent forth words against God. The Most High then passed sentence on them. From their seed the Giants are said to have been born. By them arts were brought forth on the earth, and they taught the dyeing of wool and everything that is done; and those mortals set up images of the dead. But the Almighty, because they were of evil seed, did not decree that they be brought back from death when they died. Hence they now wander and ruin many bodies; above all these are the ones you worship today and pray to as gods.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Gen 6:2 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 6:4 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The gods are the spirits of the Giants born of fallen angels and women, who now wander as demons.

  • The acrostic spells CVLTVRA DAEMONVM. The story of the watchers and the Giants, who taught arts such as dyeing, follows Gen 6:1–4 as expanded in 1 Enoch 6–8 and 15.
  • “in term artis” is corrupt in the digital text; translated by sense (“arts … on the earth”).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (line-break hyphen and stray letter): Cum- m Deus → Cum Deus.

Extrabiblical texts: 1 En. 6-8 (1 Enoch [in the ETH canon]; allusion); 1 En. 15.8 (1 Enoch [in the ETH canon]; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.3 (CSEL 15:7–8; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.4CSEL 15:8

IIII. SATVRNVS. Saturnusque senex si deus, deus quando senescit? / Aut si deus erat, cur natos ille uorabat? / Terroribus actus, sed quia deus non erat ille, / Viscera natorum rabie monstruosa sumebat. / Rex fuit in terris, in monte natus Olympo, / Nec erat diuinus; sic deum esse dicebat. / Venit inops animi, lapidem pro filio sorpsit: / Sic deus euasit; dicitur modo Iuppiter ille.

Saturn. If old Saturn is a god, when does a god grow old? Or if he was a god, why did he devour his children? He was driven by terrors; but because he was not a god, he consumed the flesh of his children in monstrous rage. He was a king on earth, born on Mount Olympus, and he was not divine; yet he said he was a god. He came, poor in mind, and swallowed a stone in place of his son; so the god escaped, the one who is now called Jupiter.

Notes and citation

Summary: Saturn, who grew old and devoured his children, was a mortal king, not a god.

  • The acrostic spells SATVRNVS. The myth of Kronos swallowing his children and a stone in place of Zeus: Hesiod, Theogony 453–491.

Extrabiblical texts: Hesiod, Theog. 453-491 (Hesiod, Theogony; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.4 (CSEL 15:8; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-4). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-4) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.5CSEL 15:8–9

V. IVPPITER. Iuppiter hic natus in insula Creta Saturno / Vt fuit adultus, patrem de regno priuauit, / Proinde nobilium uxores sororesque delusit.. / Praeterea sceptra fecerat faber illi Pyracmon. > / - Initio caelum, terram Deus et mare fecit; / Terribilis autem iste medio tempore natus s / Ex antro processit iuuenis furtimque nutritus. / Respice querellas! Alter est Deus, non Iouis ille.

Jupiter. This Jupiter, born to Saturn on the island of Crete, when he had grown up deprived his father of his kingdom, and then seduced the wives and sisters of nobles. Moreover, the smith Pyracmon had made him his scepter. In the beginning God made heaven, earth, and sea; but this terrible one, born in the middle of time, came out of a cave as a youth, having been nursed in secret. Consider the charges! The true God is another, not that Jupiter.

Gen 1:1 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Jupiter, born in time on Crete, dethroned his father and seduced women; he is not the God who made heaven and earth.

  • The acrostic spells IVPPITER. Pyracmon is one of the Cyclopes (Virgil, Aen. 8.425). “In the beginning God made heaven …”: Gen 1:1.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.5 (CSEL 15:8–9; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-5). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-5) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.6CSEL 15:9–11

VI. DE FVLMINE IPSIVS IOVIS AVDITE. Dicitis o stulti: Iouis tonat, fulminat ipse. / Etsi paruulitas sic sensit, cur anni dicentes? / Fuistis infantes: numquid et semper eritis? / Versari maturum 〈in〉 infantia non capit aeuum. / Lusus puerilis cessit: sic et corda recedant; / Moribus utique consilia uestra debentur. / Insipiens ergo Iouem tonitruare tu credis / Natum hic in terris et lacte caprino nutritum; / Ergo si illum deuorasset * * Saturnus, / In istis temporibus quis pluebat illo defuncto? / Praesertim mortali patre deus nasci credatur? / Saturnus in terris senuit et defecit in ipsis. / Illum non aliquis prophetauit ante pronasci. / Vel, si tonat ipse, lex ab ipso lata fuisset. / Seducunt historiae fat(u)os confictae 〈inanes〉. / Ille autem Cretae regnauit et ibi defecit. / Omnipotens nobis factus Semeles amator. / Viuus ipse modo amaret similiter [si uiuere] ille. / Inpuros oratis et dicitis esse caelestes / Semine mortali natos de Gigantibus illis. / Auditis et legitis natum in terra fuisse: / Vnde bene meruit corruptor ascendere caelum? / Dicitur et fulmen Cyclopas illi fecisse, / Inmortalis enim habuit a mortalibus arma. / Tot reum criminibus, parricidam quoque suorum, / Ex auctoritate uestra contulistis in altum.

Hear about the thunderbolt of Jupiter himself. You say, you fools: “Jupiter thunders; he hurls the lightning himself.” Even if childishness thought so, why do you say it when grown in years? You were children: will you always be so? A mature age cannot keep living in infancy. Childish play has passed; so let childish hearts withdraw too; your counsels surely ought to match your conduct. Foolish one, then, do you believe that Jupiter thunders, who was born here on earth and nursed with goat's milk? So if Saturn had devoured him, who would have sent the rain in those times, with him dead? Above all, is a god to be believed born of a mortal father? Saturn grew old on earth and died there. No one prophesied beforehand that he would be born. Or, if he thunders, a law would have been given by him. Made-up (empty) stories lead the foolish astray. He reigned in Crete and died there. Your almighty became Semele's lover; if he were alive now, he would love likewise. You pray to impure beings and call them heavenly, born of mortal seed from those Giants. You hear and read that he was born on earth: how did the corrupter deserve to go up to heaven? It is said too that the Cyclopes made his thunderbolt: so the immortal had his weapons from mortals. One guilty of so many crimes, a murderer of his own kin too, you have raised on high on your own authority.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Notes and citation

Summary: It is childish to believe that Jupiter, a mortal born on earth and dead in Crete, thunders from heaven.

  • The acrostic spells DE FVLMINE IPSIVS IOVIS AVDITE. The editor deletes “si uiuere” and marks a gap (* *); words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements. ANF's text names Alcmena instead of Semele.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR Y for V): Yiuus → Viuus.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.6 (CSEL 15:9–11; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-6). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-6) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.7CSEL 15:11–12

VII. DE SEPTIZONIO ET STELLIS. De circulo zonae fallit uos imperitia uestra, / Ex eo quod forte Iouem experitis orandum. / Saturnus fertur ibi, sed stella, non ille; effugit / Expulsus a Ioue. Aut Iouis in stella credatur? / Poli quoque sidera tractauit solusque sator, / Troianis qui bellum fecit, auem mortalem amauit. / Ipsis sideribus aut Mars qui cum ipsa deprensus / Zelo maritali deus nominetur aduliscens? / O nimium stulti, qui putatis moechos ab astris / Nascentes regere aut totam mundi naturam. / In uulnera positi et ipsi sub fata uiuentes, / Obsceni, furiosi, bellatores, impii uitae, / Et filios totidem mortales illi fecere: / Terribilis omnis, stulti, septizonio fortis! / Si stellas colitis, colite et bis sena sigilla! / Tam arietem, taurum, geminos toruumque leonem / Et dein quae uadunt in piscis tu quoque probabis. / Lex sine lege, fuga uestra, quod uult esse ualebit. / Lasciua uult esse, sine freno uiuere quaerit. / Ipsi quod uultis erit, et deos et deas oratis. / Sic ego colui, dum erraui, quod modo culpo.

On the Septizonium and the stars. Your ignorance deceives you about the circle of the zodiac, since you think perhaps that Jupiter is to be prayed to. Saturn is said to be there, but it is a star, not he; he fled, driven out by Jupiter. Or is Jupiter to be believed to be in a star? And did he, the sole begetter, handle the stars of the pole — he who made war on the Trojans and, as a bird, loved a mortal? Or among the stars themselves is Mars, who was caught with her through a husband's jealousy, to be called a young god? You utter fools, who think that adulterers born from the stars rule, or govern the whole nature of the world! Themselves open to wounds and living under the fates, obscene, raging, warlike, ungodly in life, those mortals also begot as many sons. Every terrible one, you fools, is powerful in the Septizonium! If you worship the stars, worship the twice six signs too! You will approve the ram, the bull, the twins, and the fierce lion, and then what goes on to the fishes. A law without law, your refuge: what it wills will prevail. Lust wills to be, and seeks to live without a bridle. What you wish will be, and you pray to gods and goddesses. So I worshiped, while I wandered, what I now condemn.

Notes and citation

Summary: Astrology is folly, for the planets bear the names of adulterous mortals, and Commodian once believed it himself.

  • The acrostic spells DE SEPTIZONIO ET STELLIS. The Septizonium is the sevenfold order of the planets. Mars caught with Venus by her husband Vulcan: Homer, Odyssey 8.266–366. Jupiter as a swan with Leda is probably meant by “as a bird, loved a mortal.”
  • Several lines are obscure (“Poli quoque sidera tractauit solusque sator”; “Lex sine lege, fuga uestra”); they are translated literally.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR 0 for O; OCR e for s; OCR n for u): 0 nimium → O nimium; mortalee → mortales; fuga uestra, quod unlt → fuga uestra, quod uult; Lasciua unlt → Lasciua uult.

Extrabiblical texts: Homer, Od. 8.266-366 (Homer, Odyssey; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.7 (CSEL 15:11–12; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-7). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-7) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.8CSEL 15:12–13

VIII. DE SOLE ET LVNA. De Sole et Luna, licet sint praesentanea nobis, / Erratis; quod ego prius putatis oranda. / Sunt quidem in astris, sed non sua sponte currunt: / Omnipotens illos, cum conderet omnia primum, / Locauit ibidem cum stellis quarta dierum. / Errorem antiquus quin cum * * * / Et quidem in lege iussit, ne quis illos adoret. / Tot deos oratis, qui nihil de uita promittunt, / Lex quorum in terra non est, nec ipsi praedicti; / Vos autem seducunt sacerdotes pauci (inanes), / Numina qui dicunt aliquid morituro prodesse. / Accedite legis 〈edictis〉 et dicite uerum.

On the sun and the moon. About the Sun and the Moon, though they are present to us, you are wrong, since you, as I once did, think they are to be prayed to. They are indeed among the heavenly bodies, but they do not run of their own accord: the Almighty, when he first founded all things, placed them there with the stars on the fourth of the days. … And indeed in the law he commanded that no one should worship them. You pray to so many gods, who promise nothing about life, whose law is not on earth and who were not foretold; but a few (empty) priests lead you astray, who say that divinities can do something for one who is about to die. Come to the (edicts) of the law and speak the truth.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Gen 1:16 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 1:19 (allusion, medium confidence) · Deut 4:19 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The sun and moon were set in place by God on the fourth day and must not be worshiped.

  • The acrostic spells DE SOLE ET LVNA. The editor marks a gap (* * *). Words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements.
  • Gen 1:14–19; the prohibition: Deut 4:19.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.8 (CSEL 15:12–13; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-8). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-8) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.9CSEL 15:13–14

VIIII. MERCVRIVS. Mercurius uester fiat cum saraballo depictus / Et galea et planta pinnatus et cetera nudus. / Rem uideo miram, deum <cum) saccello uolare: / Currite pauperculi cum gremio quo uolat ille, / Vt sacculum effundat, uos extunc estote parati. / Respicite pictum, quoniam uobis hic ab alto / Iactabit nummos; uos tunc saltate securi. / Vane, non insanis, colere deos pictos in axe? / Si uir esse nescis, cum besteis perge morari.

Mercury. Let your Mercury be painted with his trousers and helmet, winged on his feet and otherwise naked. I see a wondrous thing: a god flying with a purse! Run, you poor folk, holding out your laps where he flies, so that he may pour out his purse; be ready from now on. Look at the picture, since he will throw coins down to you from on high; then dance without a care. Foolish one, are you not mad to worship gods painted on a board? If you do not know how to be a man, go and live with the beasts.

Notes and citation

Summary: Mercury, painted with his purse, is a picture, not a god.

  • The acrostic spells MERCVRIVS. “saraballum” is a kind of loose trousers; the sense of the word here is uncertain.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR B for R): MERCVBIVS. → MERCVRIVS..

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.9 (CSEL 15:13–14; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-9). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-9) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.10CSEL 15:14–15

X. NEPTVNVS. Neptunum facitis deum ex Saturno pronatum, / Et tridentem regit, ut pisces suffigere possit. / Patet esse deum: humerale illi parate! / Troianis non ipse cum Apolline muros eduxit? / Vnde deus factus inops caementarius ille? / Non Cyclopem genuit monstrum? non moechus et ipse? / Viuere non poterat de suo, quod structuram gerebat. / Sic genuit generatus, qui fuit iam mortuus olim.

Neptune. You make Neptune a god, born of Saturn, and he wields a trident so that he can spear fish. Plainly he is a god — prepare him a porter's shoulder-pad! Did he not build walls for the Trojans with Apollo? How did the god become a needy mason? Did he not beget the monster Cyclops? Was he not an adulterer himself? He could not live on his own means, since he took on building work. So the begotten begot — one who died long ago.

Notes and citation

Summary: Neptune, a fisherman, hired mason, and adulterer, was a mortal.

  • The acrostic spells NEPTVNVS. Neptune and Apollo building the walls of Troy for Laomedon: Homer, Iliad 21.441–457. Neptune as father of the Cyclops Polyphemus: Odyssey 1.68–73.

Extrabiblical texts: Homer, Il. 21.441-457 (Homer, Iliad; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.10 (CSEL 15:14–15; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-10). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-10) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.11CSEL 15:15–16

XI. APOLLO SORTILEGVS FALSVS. Apollinem facitis citharoedum atque diuinum. / Primum de moechia natus in insula Delo; / Oblata mercede postmodum structuram secutus / Laomedonti regi Troianorum muros eduxit / Locauitque sese, quem deum seducti putatis; / Ossibus cuius amor Cassandrae flagrauit, / Subdole quem lusit uirgo, falliturque diuinus, / Officio uerbenis 〈non〉 potuit scire bicordem; / Repudiatus enim discessit inde diuinus. / Torruit hunc uirgo specie, quam ille deberet. / Illa prior utique debuerat deum amasse. / Lasciuientemque Dafinem sic coepit amare. / Et tamen insequitur, dum uult uiolare puellam: / Gratis amat stultus, nec potuit consequi cursu. / Vel, si deus erat, occurreret illi per auras: / Sub tectis illa prior uenit, remansitque diuinus. / Fallit uos gens hominum, nam ui robusti fuerunt. / A primitia quoque pecora pauisse refertur. / Lusibus in positis dum mitteret discum in altum, / Sublapsum non potuit retinere, prostrauit amicum: / Vltimus ille dies fuit Hyacinthi sodalis. / Si diuinus erat, mortem praecessisset amici.

Apollo, the false soothsayer. You make Apollo a harper and a diviner. First, he was born of adultery on the island of Delos; later, following the builder's trade for a wage offered, he built walls for Laomedon, king of the Trojans, and hired himself out — he whom, led astray, you think a god. Love for Cassandra burned in his bones; the virgin tricked him craftily, and the diviner was deceived: by his office with the sacred boughs he could not know her double heart; rejected, the diviner went away. The virgin burned him with her beauty, whom he ought … She at least ought to have loved a god first. Then he began to love Daphne, who was sporting, and still he pursues her, wanting to violate the girl: the fool loves in vain, and could not catch her in the race. Or, if he was a god, he would have met her through the air: she reached shelter first, and the diviner was left behind. The race of men deceives you; for these were men of great strength. He is also said at first to have fed flocks. In the games, when he threw the discus on high, he could not hold it as it fell back, and laid his friend low: that was the last day of his companion Hyacinthus. If he was a diviner, he would have forestalled his friend's death.

Notes and citation

Summary: Apollo, deceived by Cassandra, outrun by Daphne, and unable to foresee Hyacinthus's death, was no diviner and no god.

  • The acrostic spells APOLLO SORTILEGVS FALSVS. Daphne and Hyacinthus: Ovid, Metamorphoses 1.452–567; 10.162–219. Apollo as herdsman of Admetus is probably meant by “fed flocks.”
  • The line “Torruit hunc uirgo specie, quam ille deberet” is incomplete in sense; translated literally. Words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR ch for cu): structuram sechtus → structuram secutus.

Extrabiblical texts: Ovid, Met. 1.452-567 (Ovid; allusion); Ovid, Met. 10.162-219 (Ovid; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.11 (CSEL 15:15–16; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-11). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-11) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.12CSEL 15:16–18

XII. LIBER PATER BACCHVS. Liberum patrem certe bis genitum dicitis ipsi. / In India natus ex Ioue Proserpina primum / Belligerans contra Titanas profuso cruore / Expirauit enim sicut ex mortalibus unus. / Rursus flato suo redditus in altero uentre. / Percepit hoc Semele iterum Iouis altera moecha, / Absciso cuius utero prope partu defunctae / Tollitur et datur Niso nutriendus alumnus. / Ex eo bis natus Dionysus ille uocatur, / Religio cuius in uacuo falsa curatur, / Bacchantur et illi, qualis nunc ipsi uidentur, / Aut t peticulones mineruionis quesutoris / Conspirant in malo, proludunt fincto furore, / Ceteros ut fallant dicturos numen adesse. / Hinc manifeste rudes homines sine le〈ge〉 uiuentes / Vino permutati, primo quod expresserat ille, / Sub ludicro suo honorem illi dedere.

Father Liber, Bacchus. You yourselves surely say that Father Liber was born twice. Born first in India of Jupiter and Proserpina, he fought against the Titans, poured out his blood, and died like any one of the mortals. He was restored again by his father's breath in another womb: Semele, another mistress of Jupiter, received him again; when her womb was cut open, as she died close to childbirth, he was taken up and given to Nysus as a foster-child to be reared. From this he is called Dionysus, the twice born, whose false religion is practiced in vain; and they revel as Bacchants, as they themselves are now seen, or … conspire in wickedness and perform with feigned frenzy, to deceive the others into saying that the god is present. Hence, plainly, rude men living without law, transformed by wine, which he first pressed out, gave him honor in his game.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Notes and citation

Summary: Bacchus, killed by the Titans and born a second time of Semele, was a mortal, and his rites are feigned frenzy.

  • The acrostic spells LIBER PATER BACCHVS. The myth of Dionysus-Zagreus torn by the Titans and reborn of Semele is Orphic.
  • The line “Aut t peticulones mineruionis quesutoris” is corrupt and cannot be construed; it is marked “…”. Words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements.

Extrabiblical texts: Orpheus (attributed), Orph. frag. (Orpheus (attributed), Orphic poems (fragments); allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.12 (CSEL 15:16–18; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-12). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-12) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.13CSEL 15:18–19

XIII. INVICTVS. Inuictus de petra natus si deus habetur, / Nunc ergo reticeo; uos de istis date priorem! / Vicit petra deum, quaerendus est petrae creator. / Insuper et furem adhuc depingitis esse, / Cum, si deus esset, utique non furto uiuebat / Terrenus utique fuit et monstruosa natura, / Vertebatque boues alienos semper in antris, / Sicut et Cacus Vulcani filius ille.

The Unconquered. If the Unconquered, born from a rock, is held to be a god, then I say no more; you tell me which of them came first! The rock conquered the god; the rock's creator must be sought. Besides, you even paint him as a thief, whereas if he were a god he certainly would not live by theft. He was surely earthly and of monstrous nature, and he was forever driving other people's cattle into caves, like Cacus, the son of Vulcan.

Notes and citation

Summary: The Unconquered god born from a rock, a cattle thief, cannot be God.

  • The acrostic spells INVICTVS. The “Unconquered” is Mithras, born from a rock and pictured with a bull; the cattle-stealing may reflect Mithraic imagery. Cacus the son of Vulcan: Virgil, Aeneid 8.190–267.

Extrabiblical texts: Virgil, Aen. 8.190-267 (Virgil; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.13 (CSEL 15:18–19; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-13). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-13) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.14CSEL 15:19

XIIII. SILVANVS. Siluanus unde deus iterum apparuit esse? / Inde forte placet, eo quod bene fistula cantat? / Largitur quoniam lignum? Nam forte non esset. / Vaenalem emisti dominum, cum tu ipse sis illi. / Aspice, deficit lignum! quid illi debetur? / Non te pudet, stulte, tales adorare tabellas? / Vnum quaere Deum, qui post mortem uiuere dicit! / Secede ab istis, qui sunt biothanati facti.

Silvanus. How did Silvanus turn out to be a god as well? Does he please, perhaps, because his pipe plays sweetly? Because he gives wood? Otherwise, perhaps, he would not exist. You bought a lord who was for sale, when you yourself are his master. Look, the wood fails! What is owed to him? Are you not ashamed, fool, to worship such boards? Seek the one God, who says that you will live after death! Withdraw from these, who have become biothanati.

Notes and citation

Summary: Silvanus, a wooden image bought for money, is no god; the one God promises life after death.

  • The acrostic spells SILVANVS. “biothanati” is a Greek loanword for those who died a violent or untimely death.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.14 (CSEL 15:19; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-14). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-14) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.15CSEL 15:19–20

XV. HERCVLES. Hercules quod monstrum Auentini montis elisit, / Euandri qui solitus erat armenta furare, / Rustica mens hominum, indocilis quoque, pro laude / Cum gratias agere uellent, absentis Tonantis / Vouerunt hostias inepto ut deo orando, / Laetandas aras in memoriam sibi fecerunt. / Ex eo perrexit, de uetusto more colatur. / Sed deus hic non est, licet fuit fortis in armis.

Hercules. Because Hercules crushed the monster of the Aventine hill, who used to steal Evander's herds, the rustic and untaught minds of men, wishing to give thanks in his praise, vowed victims to the absent Thunderer, as though praying to a foolish god, and made altars to feast at in memory of it. From that it went on that he is worshiped by ancient custom. But he is not a god, though he was strong in arms.

Notes and citation

Summary: Hercules was honored for killing Cacus, but he was a strong man, not a god.

  • The acrostic spells HERCVLES. Hercules killing Cacus on the Aventine and the founding of the Ara Maxima: Virgil, Aeneid 8.190–305.

Extrabiblical texts: Virgil, Aen. 8.190-305 (Virgil; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.15 (CSEL 15:19–20; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-15). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-15) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.16CSEL 15:20–21

XVI. DE DIS DEABVSQVE. Dicitis esse deos, qui sunt manifeste cruenti, / Et dicitis fata genesis adscribere nobis? / Dicite nunc ergo, quibus primum sacra ferantur: / Inter utrumque uias mors inmatura uagatur. / Si tribuunt fata genesis, cur deum oratis? / Deciperis, uane, qui Manes quaeris orare, / Et qui fabricantur dominos tibi nuncupas esse. / Aut feminas quoque nescio quas deas oratis, / Bellonam et Nemesim, deas Furinam, Caelestem, / Virgines, et Venerem, cui coniuges uestrae delumbant. / Sunt alia praeterea daemonia (procul a) fanis, / Quae nec numerantur adhuc et in collo feruntur, / Vt nec ipsi sibi rationem reddere possint [pestes]. / Exportari magis in ultima terra deberent.

On the gods and goddesses. You say they are gods who are plainly bloodthirsty, and you say that the fates assign us our birth? Tell me now, then, to which of the two sacrifices should be offered first: between the two, untimely death roams the roads. If the fates assign our birth, why do you pray to a god? You are deceived, vain one, who seek to pray to the spirits of the dead, and who call things that are manufactured your lords. Or you also pray to women, goddesses of some sort, Bellona and Nemesis, the goddesses Furina and Caelestis, the Virgins, and Venus, for whom your wives wear themselves out. There are other demons besides, (away from) the temples, which are not even counted yet and are carried around the neck, so that they cannot even give an account of themselves. They ought rather to be carried off to the ends of the earth.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Notes and citation

Summary: The pagan gods and goddesses, the fates, and the amulet-demons worn around the neck are all empty.

  • The acrostic spells DE DIS DEABVSQVE. The editor deletes “pestes” (“plagues”) at the end of a line. Caelestis is the goddess of Carthage.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (stray letter): DEABVSQVE. I Dicitis → DEABVSQVE. Dicitis.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.16 (CSEL 15:20–21; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-16). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-16) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.17CSEL 15:21–23

XVII. DE SIMVLACRIS EORVM. Deludunt uos pauci scelerati uates inanes, / Extricare suam dum quaerunt * * uitam. / Subornant aliis ex se sub mysteria falsum. / Inde simulantes concussi numine quodam / Maiestatemque canunt et se sub figura fatigant. / Vidistis saepe Duellonarios, quali fragore / Luxurias ineunt, dum furias fingere quaerunt, / Aut cum dorsa sua allidunt parca bipinne, / Cum doctrina sua cernant, quod cruore sanent. / Respicite, quoniam non illos numina cogunt, / Ipsi qui se primum conponunt integra mente; / Sed stipem ut tollant ingenia talia quaerunt. / Ex eo uidete, quoniam sunt omnia ficta. / Obumbrant populum supplicem, perituri ne credant. / Res semel in uano de uetustate processit, Vt uaticinanti credantur prodita falsa; / Maiestas autem illorum nulla locuta est.

On their images. A few wicked, empty seers delude you while they seek to scrape together their own living … They put others of their own up to a falsehood under the name of mysteries. Then, pretending to be shaken by some divinity, they chant of its majesty and wear themselves out in a disguise. You have often seen the priests of Bellona, with what din they enter on their excesses, while they try to feign frenzy, or when they strike their backs with a sparing double axe, since they see by their training that they heal with blood. Consider that it is not the divinities that drive them, since they first compose themselves with a sound mind; they devise such tricks to collect money. See from this that it is all made up. They cast a shadow over the suppliant people, so that those who are perishing may not believe. The thing once set out in vain from antiquity, so that false things uttered by a soothsayer are believed; but no majesty of theirs has ever spoken.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Notes and citation

Summary: Pagan seers and the frenzied priests of Bellona feign possession to get money.

  • The acrostic spells DE SIMVLACRIS EORVM. The editor marks a gap (* *). “Duellonarii” are the devotees of Bellona, who cut themselves in their rites.
  • The line “Cum doctrina sua cernant, quod cruore sanent” is obscure; translated literally.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.17 (CSEL 15:21–23; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-17). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-17) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.18CSEL 15:23–24

XVIII. DE AMMVDATE ET DEO MAGNO. Diximus iam multa de superstitione nefanda, / Et tamen exsequimur, ne quid praeterisse dicamur. / Ammudatem qui suum cultores more colebant, / Magnus erat illis, quando fuit aurum in aede;, / Mittebant capita sub numine quasi praesenti. / Ventum est ad summum, ut Caesar tolleret aurum: / Defecit numen uel fugit aut transit in ignem. / Auctor huius sceleris constat, qui formabat eundem., / Tot uiros et magnos seduxit false prophetans, / Et modo reticuit qui solebat esse diuinus. / Erumpebat enim uocis quasi mente mutata, / Tamquam illi deus ligni loqueretur in aurem. / Dicite nunc ipsi, si non sunt numina falsa, / Ex eo prodigio quot perdidit ille propheta. / Oblitus est iste prophetare, qui ante solebat. / Monstra deo ista fincta sunt per uiniuoraces, / Audacia quorum damnabilis numina fingit. / Gestabatur enim et aluit tale sigillum: / Nunc et ipse silet, nec ullus de illo prophetat. / O nimium sed〈ulo〉 uos ipsos perdere uultis.

On Ammudates and the great god. We have already said much about this unspeakable superstition, and yet we go on, so that we may not be said to have passed anything over. Ammudates, whom his worshipers used to worship in their fashion, was great to them while there was gold in the temple; they bowed their heads beneath the divinity as though it were present. It came to the point that Caesar took away the gold: the divinity failed, or fled, or passed into the fire. The author of this wickedness is well known, the man who shaped the god; he led so many great men astray with false prophesying, and now he has fallen silent, who used to be a diviner. For he used to burst out in speech as though his mind were changed, as if the god of wood were speaking into his ear. Tell me now yourselves whether the divinities are not false, and how many that prophet ruined by that portent. He has forgotten how to prophesy, who used to do it before. These wonders were invented for the god by wine-guzzlers, whose damnable audacity invents divinities. Such a figurine was carried about and fed; now it too is silent, and no one prophesies about it. O, all too eagerly you want to destroy yourselves!

Notes and citation

Summary: When Caesar took the gold from the temple of Ammudates, the god and his prophet fell silent, showing the cult was a fraud.

  • The acrostic spells DE AMMVDATE ET DEO MAGNO. Ammudates is not otherwise known (perhaps a Syrian god); which emperor removed the temple gold is uncertain.
  • Words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR 0 for O; OCR i for u; OCR letters; OCR n for m): Dixinus → Diximus; siperstitione → superstitione; eiim uoeis → enim uocis; 0 nimium → O nimium.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.18 (CSEL 15:23–24; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-18). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-18) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.19CSEL 15:24–26

XVIIII. NEMESIACIS VANIS. Non ignominium est uirum seduci prudentem / Et colere tale 〈a〉 m aut Dianam dicere lignum? / Mane ebrio, crudo, perituro creditis uno, / Ex arte qui fincte loquitur quod illi uidetur; / Seuere 〈diúinum〉 dum agit, sibi uiscera pascit. / Incopriat ciues unus detestabilis omnes / Adplicuitque sibi similis collegio facto, / Cum quibus historiam fingit, ut deum adornet. / Ipse sibi nescit diuinare, ceteris audet. / Succollat, quando libet, eum, et quando, deponit; / Vertitur a se〈se〉 rotans cum ligno bifurci, / Ac si putes illum adflatum numine ligni. / Non deos uos colitis, quos isti false prophetant: / Ipsos sacerdotes colitis in uano timentes. / Sed si corde uiges, fuge iam sacraria mortis.

To the vain devotees of Nemesis. Is it not a disgrace for a sensible man to be led astray, to worship such a thing and to call a piece of wood Diana? In the morning you believe one man, drunk, raw from wine, doomed to perish, who by his art falsely says whatever he pleases; while he sternly plays the diviner, he is feeding his own belly. One detestable man makes all the citizens drunk and gathers men like himself, forming a guild, with whom he makes up a story to adorn the god. He cannot divine for himself, yet he dares to for others. He shoulders the god when he likes and puts him down when he likes; he spins round and round with the forked pole, so that you would think him inspired by the divinity of the wood. It is not gods you worship, whom these men prophesy falsely: you worship the priests themselves, fearing in vain. But if you are strong in heart, flee now the shrines of death.

Notes and citation

Summary: The devotees of Nemesis are fooled by drunken priests who carry and spin a wooden image and pretend to divine.

  • The acrostic spells NEMESIACIS VANIS. “Incopriat” is unclear in the Latin (perhaps “inebriat,” “makes drunk”); translated by sense. Words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (footnote number of the printed edition): lignum?1 → lignum?.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.19 (CSEL 15:24–26; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-19). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-19) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.20CSEL 15:26

XX. TITANES. Titanas uobis tutanos dicitis esse; / Ita Mutas, Tacitas sub culmine uestro rogatis, / Tot Lares aediculis, simulacra facta Titano! / Adoratis enim stulti malo leto defunctos, / Non legem ipsorum legentes; non ipsi loquuntur, / Et deos audetis eramine dicere fusos? / Solueretis eos magis in uascula uobis.

The Titans. You say the Titans are your protectors; so you pray to the Silent and Quiet goddesses under your roof, to so many Lares in little shrines, images made for a Titan! Fools, you worship those who died an evil death, not reading their law; they do not speak themselves, and do you dare to call things cast in bronze gods? You would do better to melt them down into little vessels for yourselves.

Notes and citation

Summary: The household gods and images of the Titans are dead men and bronze.

  • The acrostic spells TITANES. “tutanos” (from Tutanus, a protecting god) is taken as “protectors.” Muta and Tacita are Roman goddesses of silence.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR n for u): sub culmine nestro → sub culmine uestro.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.20 (CSEL 15:26; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-20). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-20) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.21CSEL 15:26–27

XXI. MONTESIANIS. Monteses deos dicitis, dominentur in auro, / Obscurati malo aliena mente iurantes. / Nam si purus animus et mens serena maneret, / Tu tibi de illis ipsi disputare deberes. / Excordaris homo, si putas, ut isti te saluent / Seu regant, seu minuant, nisi quid tu fani decurris. / Iustitiam legis quaere magis quam illa; salutis / Auxilium portat et fieri dicit aeternum. / Nam quicquid in uano sequeris, per tempora gaudes, / In breui laetaris et postmodum plangis in imis: / Subtrahe te illis, si uis resurgere Christo.

To the Montesians. You say that the mountain gods are lords in gold, you who are darkened by evil and swear with an alien mind. For if your spirit were pure and your mind remained calm, you ought to reason out for yourself what they are. You are out of your senses, man, if you think that they save you, or rule, or diminish anything, unless you run to the temple. Seek the justice of the law rather than those things; it brings the help of salvation and says that you will become eternal. For whatever you pursue in vain, you enjoy for a season; you are glad for a short time and afterward you lament in the depths. Withdraw from them if you want to rise again to Christ.

Notes and citation

Summary: The mountain gods cannot save; the law of God offers eternal salvation to those who leave them.

  • The acrostic spells MONTESIANIS. Who the “Montesians” were is uncertain (perhaps worshipers of mountain deities). Several lines are obscure and are translated by sense.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.21 (CSEL 15:26–27; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-21). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-21) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.22CSEL 15:27–29

XXII. HEBETVDO SAECVLI. Heu doleo, ciues, sic uos hebetari de mundo! / Excurrit alius ad sortes, aues aspicit alter, / Belantum cruore fuso malus inspicit alter / Et cupit audire responsa bona crudelis. / Tot duces et reges ubi sunt consulti de uita, / Vel portenta sua scisse quo profuit illis? / Discite quaeso bonum, ciues, simulacra cauete: / Omnipotentis enim in legem quaerite cuncti. / Sic ipsi conplacuit domino dominorum in altis, / Ad probationem nostram daemones in mundo uag(ar)i. / Et tamen ex alia parte mandata praemisit, / Caelestis fieri qui relinquant aras eorum. / Vnde non hoc curo disputare paruo libello: / Lex docet in medio; uos consulete pro nobis! / In duas intrastis uias: condiscite rectam.

The dullness of the age. Alas, I grieve, citizens, that you are so dulled by the world! One runs off to the lots, another watches birds, another wickedly inspects the blood of bleating victims poured out and cruelly longs to hear favorable answers. So many generals and kings who took counsel about their lives — where are they? Or what good did it do them to have known their omens? Learn the good, I beg you, citizens; beware of images; all of you, search into the law of the Almighty. It has so pleased the Lord of lords on high himself that demons should roam the world to test us. And yet, on the other side, he has sent ahead commandments, that those who abandon their altars should become heavenly. So I do not care to argue this in a little book: the law teaches openly; consult it on our behalf! You have set out on two roads: learn the right one.

Deut 30:15 (echo, low confidence) · Matt 7:13 (echo, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Commodian laments pagan divination and urges his fellow citizens to seek the law of God and choose the right road.

  • The acrostic spells HEBETVDO SAECVLI. The two roads: compare Deut 30:15–19; Matt 7:13–14.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (line number of the printed edition): rectam. 15 → rectam..

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.22 (CSEL 15:27–29; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-22). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-22) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.23CSEL 15:29–30

XXIII. DE VBIQVE PARATIS. Dum uentri seruis, innocentem esse te dicis, / Et quasi communis facis te ubique paratum. / Vae tibi, stulte homo, mortem circumspicis ipse,. / Barbaro de more sine lege uiuere quaeris: / Ipse tibi figis asciam in crure de uerbo. / Qui simplicem fingis, simpliciter uiuo cum isto / Viuere te credis, dum uentrem cupis implere? / Exiguus tyranni in domo resides, praue, / Paratus ad epulas, et refugis Dei praecepta. / Aut quia discredis Deum iudicare defunctos, / Rectorem caeli facis te tute pro illo? / Aspicis ad uentrem, quasi tu sis prouidus illi. / Tu modo profanus, modo sanctus esse uideris. / In supplicem prodis Dei sub aspectu tyranni. / Senties in fatis, cuias modo leges inanis.

To those ready for anything. While you serve your belly, you say you are innocent, and as though you were everyone's friend you make yourself ready for anything. Woe to you, foolish man; you are staring death in the face yourself. You seek to live without law, in the manner of a barbarian: by your own word you drive an axe into your own leg. You who feign simplicity — do you think you are living simply with him, while you long to fill your belly? You sit, petty and wicked, in a tyrant's house, ready for feasts, and you shun God's commands. Or, because you disbelieve that God judges the dead, do you make yourself ruler of heaven in his place? You look to your belly, as though you were its provider. Now you seem profane, now holy. You betray God's suppliant before the eyes of the tyrant. You will feel among the fates whose empty laws you now follow.

Phil 3:19 (echo, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Commodian rebukes the time-server who, for the sake of his belly, is ready for anything and betrays God's people to a tyrant.

  • The acrostic spells DE VBIQVE PARATIS. Several lines are obscure (for example “simpliciter uiuo cum isto” and the last line); they are translated by sense.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.23 (CSEL 15:29–30; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-23). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-23) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.24CSEL 15:30–32

XXIIII. INTER VTRVMQVE VIVENTIBVS. Inter utrumque putans dubie uiuendo cauere, / Nudatus a lege, decrepitus luxu praesepis, / Tot (uana) nane prospicis; quid? quaeris iniqua! / Et quidquid egistis, istinc remanere defuncto / Respicite. Stulte, non eras, et ecce uideris! / Vnde processisti nescis nec unde nutriris. / Tu Deum excelsum fugis tuae uitae benignum / Rectoremque tuum, qui te magis uiuere uellet; / Vertis te in faciem et dorsum Deo remittis, / Mergis te in tenebris, dum putas te in luce morari. / Quid in synagoga decurris saepe bifarius? / Vt tibi misericors fiat quem denegas ultro? / Exis inde foris, iterum tu fana requiris; / Vis inter utrumque uiuere, sed inde peribis. / Insuper et dicis: Quis est, qui a morte rediuit / Vt credamus ei, quoniam ibi poenae aguntur. / Ea non sunt sic, ut tu putas esse, maligne! / Nam illi qui prodest, post funera recte qui uixit? / Tu tamen mox moreris, duceris in loco maligno; / In Christo credentes autem in loco benigno, / Blanditurque quibus haeret amoenitas illa. / Vos autem dabitis uiui sine corpore poenas;. / Suscitat in faciem tortoris ordo clamare.

To those who live between the two. Thinking to be safe by living doubtfully between the two, stripped of the law, worn out by the luxury of the manger, you look ahead to so many (vain) things; what for? You seek what is wicked! And whatever you have done, see that it stays here when you are dead. Fool, you did not exist, and behold, you are seen! You do not know where you came from, nor where you are fed from. You flee God on high, who is kind to your life, and your ruler, who would rather you lived; you turn to your own face and turn your back to God; you plunge yourself into darkness while you think you are dwelling in light. Why do you run into the synagogue so often, double-minded? So that he may show mercy to you, whom you freely deny? You go out from there and again you seek out the temples. You want to live between the two, but by it you will perish. And besides you say: “Who is there who has come back from death, so that we may believe him that punishments are carried out there?” These things are not as you think they are, wicked one! For what does it profit one who lived rightly, after death? Yet you will soon die and be led to an evil place, but those who believe in Christ to a kind place, and that loveliness caresses those to whom it clings. But you will pay the penalty alive, without the body; the order of things will rouse you to cry out before the torturer's face.

Luke 16:30 (echo, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Commodian warns those who go both to the synagogue and to the temples that they will perish, since punishment and reward await after death.

  • The acrostic spells INTER VTRVMQVE VIVENTIBVS. The persons addressed attend the synagogue and also pagan temples.
  • The line “Nam illi qui prodest, post funera recte qui uixit?” is ambiguous; it may continue the objector's words. Round brackets are the editor's supplements.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR Y for V): Yos autem → Vos autem.

Topics: Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.24 (CSEL 15:30–32; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-24). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-24) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.25CSEL 15:32–33

XXV. QVI TIMENT ET NON CREDENT. Quamdiu, stulte homo, Christum cognoscere non uis? / Vitas agrum pinguem et sterili semina iactas. / In silua manere quaeris, ubi latro moratur. / Tu dicis: Et ego Dei sum, et foras oberras. / Ingredere iam nunc totiens inuitatus in aula: / Matura iam messis, tempus totidemque paratum, / Ecce modo mete; quodsi non, te paenitet inde. / Nunc, si non habes, collige; uindemia uenit; / Tempus adest uitae credendi tempore mortis. / Est Dei lex prima fundamentum posterae legis, / Teque designabat. Crede sis in lege secunda; / Nec minus t ex ipsos et ex ipsas ibi prudentes; / Obstupe iam factus ora tu credere Christo, / Nam testamentum uetus de isto proclamat. / Credere nun(c) opus est, tantum in isto defuncto / Resurgere posse 〈et〉 uiuere tempore toto. / Ergo si quis ea discredit esse futura, / Dummodo uincetur reus in morte secunda, / Euentura canam paucis in isto libello; / Nam cognosci potest, ubi sit spes uitae ponenda. / Tamen uos adhortor quantocius credere Christo.

Those who fear and do not believe. How long, foolish man, will you refuse to know Christ? You avoid the rich field and throw seed on barren ground. You want to stay in the forest where the robber lurks. You say: “I too belong to God,” and you wander outside. Come into the hall now, you who have been invited so often: the harvest is ripe now, and the time just as ready; see, reap now; if not, you will regret it. Now, if you have nothing, gather; the vintage has come; the time of life is at hand for believing, in the time of death. God's first law is the foundation of the later law, and it pointed to you. Believe, so that you may be in the second law; … Now that you are amazed, pray to believe in Christ; for the old testament proclaims him. Now it is needful to believe only this: that in him who died one can rise again and live for all time. So if anyone disbelieves that these things will come, until he is convicted as guilty in the second death, I will sing of what is to come in a few words in this little book; for it can be known where the hope of life should be placed. Still, I urge you to believe in Christ as quickly as you can.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Matt 13:8 (echo, low confidence) · John 4:35 (echo, medium confidence) · Luke 14:23 (echo, low confidence) · Rev 20:14 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Commodian urges the God-fearers who hold back from faith to believe in Christ, whom the old law foretold.

  • The acrostic spells QVI TIMENT ET NON CREDENT. Those addressed are probably Gentile “God-fearers” attached to the synagogue.
  • The line “Nec minus t ex ipsos et ex ipsas ibi prudentes” is corrupt and is marked “…”. Words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR n for u; OCR w for u): nnn(c) → nun(c); Euentwra → Euentura.

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.25 (CSEL 15:32–33; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-25). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-25) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.26CSEL 15:33–36

XXVI. REPVGNANTIBVS ADVERSVS LEGEM CHRISTI DEI VIVI. Respuis, infelix, bonum disciplinae caelestis / Et ruis in mortem, dum uis sine freno uagari. / Perdunt te luxuriae et breuia gaudia mundi, /. Vnde sub inferno cruciaberis tempore toto. / Gaudia sunt uana, quibus oblectaris, inepte. / Non illa te reddunt hominem fuisse defunctum. / Anni te non possunt iam triginta reddere doctum?.. / Nescius si primum errasti, respice canum. / Tu putas nunc uitam isti te perfrui laetum? / Iniuriae, lites ibi sunt et damna diurnum, / Bella uel infanda, fraudes, cum sanguine furta, / Vlceribus corpus uexatur, gemiturque, ploratur, / Seu luis inuadit, aut longo morbo teneris, / Aut natis orbaris, aut perdita coniuge defles; / Destruitur totum, ruunt dignitates ab alto; / Vreris pauperie dupliciter certe si langues: / Et dicis uitam, ubi uitrea uita moraris? / Respice iam tandem hoc tempus inritum esse: / Sed in futuro tibi spes est sine dolo uiuendi. / Viuere uolebat utique 〈pater〉 paruoli rapti; / Sed uita priuati iuuenis et senescere forte, / Lautitias diues perfrui quia ipse parabat; / Et tamen inuiti reli〈n〉 quimus omnia mundo.- / Gens et ego fui peruersa mente moratus- / Et uitam istius saeculi ueram esse putabam / Mortemque similiter sicut uos iudicabam adesse, / Cum semel exisset, animum periisse defunctum. / Haec autem sic non sunt; sed conditor orbis et auctor — / Requisiuit enim fratrem a fratre peremptum —: / Impie, dic, inquit, ubinam frater? — Ille negauit. — / Sanguis enim fratris ad me proclamauit in altum. / Torqueris, uideo, ubi nil sentire putabas, / Ille autem uiuit et loca dextera tenet, / Delicias fruitur, quas tu perdidisti, nefande! / Et cum renouasti(s) saeculum, et ille praegressus / Inmortalis erit; nam tu sub tartara planges. / Viuit certe Deus, qui defunctos uiuere fecit, / Innocuisque bonis ut reddat praemia digna, / Vesanis autem et impiis tartara saeua. / Incipe sentire iudicia Dei, seducte!

To those who resist the law of Christ, the living God. Unhappy one, you spit out the good of the heavenly discipline and rush into death while you want to roam without a bridle. Luxuries and the brief joys of the world are destroying you, for which you will be tormented in hell for all time. The joys you delight in, you fool, are empty; they will not show, when you are dead, that you were a man. Can thirty years not make you wise yet? If you went astray at first in ignorance, look at your grey hair. Do you think you are now happily enjoying life here? Here there are injuries, lawsuits, and daily losses, wars and unspeakable things, frauds, thefts with bloodshed; the body is racked with sores, there is groaning and weeping; or plague invades, or you are held by a long illness, or you are bereaved of your children, or you weep for a wife you have lost; everything is destroyed, honors fall from on high; poverty burns you, doubly if you are sick; and do you call it life, where you linger in a life of glass? Consider at last that this time is worthless; but in the future you have the hope of living without grief. The (father) of a little one snatched away surely wanted him to live; but the young man deprived of life might perhaps have grown old too, because the rich man himself was getting ready to enjoy his luxuries; and yet, unwilling, we leave everything to the world. I too was a Gentile, living with a perverse mind, and I thought the life of this age was the true one, and I judged, as you do, that when death came and the soul had once gone out, the dead man had perished. But these things are not so: the founder and author of the world — for he required of the brother the brother who had been slain — said: “Ungodly one, tell me, where is your brother?” He denied it. “For your brother's blood has cried out to me on high.” You are tormented, I see, where you thought you would feel nothing; but he lives and holds the places on the right hand, enjoying the delights that you have lost, wicked one! And when the age has been renewed, he too, having gone before, will be immortal; but you will lament beneath Tartarus. God surely lives, who has made the dead live, to give fitting rewards to the harmless and good, but cruel Tartarus to the mad and the ungodly. Begin to feel God's judgments, you who have been led astray!

Gen 4:9 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 4:10 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: This life is full of misery, while God, who required Abel's blood of Cain, will reward the good and punish the wicked after death.

  • The acrostic spells REPVGNANTIBVS ADVERSVS LEGEM CHRISTI DEI VIVI. Cain and Abel: Gen 4:9–10.
  • Words in angle brackets are the editor's supplements. The lines about the father and the child are obscure and are translated literally.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR B for R): ADVEBSVS → ADVERSVS.

Topics: Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.26 (CSEL 15:33–36; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-26). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-26) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.27CSEL 15:36–37

XXVII. STVLTE, NON PERMORERIS DEO. Stulte, non permoreris nec mortuus effugis actus, / Tu licet disponas nihil te sentire defunctum. / Vinceris, insipiens: uiuit Deus conditor orbis, / Legitima cuius clamat(ur) ualere defunctum. / Tu autem dum praeceps sine Deo uiuere quaeris, / Extinctum in fatis indicari tu futile credis. / Non ita disposuit, ut tu putas, Deus aeternus, / Obliuitos esse mortuos de gesto priore. / Nunc nobis imperitis fecit receptacula mortis, / Post cineres autem nostros uidebimus illa. / Erue te, stulte, qui putas, post funera non sis. / Rectorem dominumque tuum nihil posse fecisti. / Mors autem in uacuum non est, si corde retractes. / Optandum noscas, nam sero senties illum. / Rector eras carnis, non te certe caro regebat; / Exemptus ab illa, reconditur illa tuorum. / Recte mortalis homo separatur a carne. / Idcirco nec poterint oculi mortales aequari — / Sic habet abyssus noster — de Dei secreta. / Da nunc ergo Deo, fragilis dum moreris, honorem, / Et crede, quod Christus uiuum te de mortuo reddit. / Omnipotenti laudes in ecclesia reddere debes.

Foolish one, you do not die altogether to God. Foolish one, you do not die altogether, nor do you escape your deeds when you are dead, though you may reckon that you will feel nothing once dead. You are refuted, senseless one: God lives, the founder of the world, whose laws are proclaimed to hold good for the dead. But while you seek headlong to live without God, you think it idle that one extinguished by fate should be judged. The eternal God did not arrange things as you think, so that the dead forget what they did before. Now he has made receptacles of death for us, who are unskilled; but after our ashes we shall see them. Pull yourself out, fool, who think you will not exist after death. You have made your ruler and lord able to do nothing. But death is not into nothingness, if you think it over in your heart. Know that it is to be desired, for you will feel him too late. You were ruler of the flesh; the flesh certainly did not rule you; once you are taken from it, it is buried by your own people. Rightly is mortal man separated from the flesh. Therefore mortal eyes cannot measure up — such is our abyss — to the secrets of God. Give honor to God now, then, while you are frail and dying, and believe that Christ raises you alive from the dead. You ought to render praises to the Almighty in the church.

Notes and citation

Summary: Death does not end existence; the dead remember their deeds and will be judged, so honor God and believe that Christ raises the dead.

  • The acrostic spells STVLTE NON PERMORERIS DEO. “permoreris” means “die completely.” Several lines are obscure (“Optandum noscas”; “Nunc nobis imperitis fecit receptacula mortis”); translated by sense. Round brackets are the editor's supplements.

Topics: Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.27 (CSEL 15:36–37; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-27). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-27) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.28CSEL 15:37–38

XXVIII. IVSTI RESVRGVNT. Iustitia et bonitas, pax et patientia uera / Viuere post fata faciunt, et queri de actu: / Subdola gens autem, noxi<os)a, perfida, praua / Tollit se in parte et fera mente moratur. / Impie, nunc audi, qui * * malefacta lucraris: / Respice terrenos iudices, in corpore qui nunc / Excruciant poenis diros: aut ferro parantur / Supplicia meritis aut longo carcere flere. / Vltime tu speras Deum inridere caelestem / Rectoremque poli, per quem sunt omnia facta? / Grassaris, insanis, detractas nunc et Dei nomen? / Vnde non effugies, poenam post fata qui ponet. / Nunc uolo sis cautus, ne uenias ignis in aestu. / Trade te iam Christo, ut te benefacta sequantur.

The righteous rise again. Justice and goodness, peace and true patience make one live after death and be questioned about one's conduct; but the deceitful, harmful, faithless, and depraved race takes itself off to one side and lives with a savage mind. Ungodly one, hear now, you who profit by evil deeds: look at earthly judges, who now torture cruel men with penalties in the body; either punishments by the sword are prepared for the guilty, or long weeping in prison. Do you hope in the end to mock the heavenly God, the ruler of the sky, through whom all things were made? You rage, you are mad, do you now even disparage God's name? You will not escape him, who will impose punishment after death. Now I want you to take care, so that you do not come into the heat of the fire. Give yourself to Christ now, so that good deeds may follow you.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

John 1:3 (echo, low confidence) · Rev 14:13 (echo, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The righteous will rise; the wicked, who fear earthly judges, will not escape God's punishment after death.

  • The acrostic spells IVSTI RESVRGVNT. The editor marks a gap (* *). “That good deeds may follow you”: compare Rev 14:13.

Topics: Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.28 (CSEL 15:37–38; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-28). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-28) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.29CSEL 15:38–40

XXVIIII. DIVITI INCREDVLO MALO. Differris, diues, nimium tua cuncta uidendo, / Insatiabiliter quibus adhuc adgerere quaeris. / Viuere post ista, dicis, non spero defunctus.! / Ingrate summo Deo, qui sic Deum indicas esse, / Te qui nescientem protulit, deinde nutriuit; / Ipse prata tua gubernat, uineas ipse, / Ipse greges pecorum et quicquid possides ipse, / Nec istis adtendis. Aut tu regis omnia forte? / Caelum hoc et terram et maria salsa qui fecit, / Reddere decreuit nos ipsos in aureo saeclo, / Et modo si credis, uiuitur in Dei secreta. / Disce Deum, stulte, qui uult te inmortalem adesse, / Vt gratias illi referas in agone perennes. / Lex docet ipsius, sed quia uagari tu quaeris, / Omnia discredis, et inde in tartaros ibis: / Mox animam reddis, duceris quo te paenitet esse, / Ac luitur ibi poena spiritalis aeterna; / Lugia sunt semper, nec permor<i) eris in illa, / Omnipotentem Deum iam tunc ibi sero proclamans.

To the wicked unbelieving rich man. You are distracted, rich man, by gazing too much at all your goods, to which you still seek insatiably to add. “After all this,” you say, “I do not hope to live once I am dead.” Ungrateful to God most high, you who declare God to be such, who brought you forth when you did not know it, then nourished you: he governs your meadows, he your vineyards, he your flocks and whatever you possess; and you pay no attention to this. Or do you perhaps govern all things? He who made this heaven and earth and the salt seas has decreed to restore us in a golden age; and now, if you believe, one lives in God's secret. Learn God, fool, who wants you to be immortal, so that you may give him thanks in the everlasting contest. His law teaches it; but because you want to roam, you disbelieve everything, and so you will go to Tartarus: soon you give back your soul, you will be led where you will regret being, and there an eternal spiritual penalty is paid; there is mourning forever, and you will not die out in it, crying out to Almighty God then, too late.

Luke 12:19 (echo, medium confidence) · Acts 4:24 (echo, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The rich unbeliever, ungrateful to God who gives him everything, will suffer eternal punishment.

  • The acrostic spells DIVITI INCREDVLO MALO. The “golden age” is Commodian's term for the coming kingdom. Compare the rich fool, Luke 12:16–21.
  • “Lugia” is unclear (perhaps for “lugubria,” “mourning”); translated by sense.

Topics: Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.29 (CSEL 15:38–40; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-29). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-29) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.30CSEL 15:40–41

XXX. DIVITES HVMILES ESTOTE. Disce, moriture, bonum ostendere cunctis. / In medio populi quid te facis alterum esse? / Vadis ubi nescis, et inscius inde recedis; / Impie tractas cum ipso corpore, sitis / Tu super diuitias, nimium te tollis in altum / Et t stifam ducis, nec respicis pauperes ultro / Subditos nunc nobis, nec parentes pascitis ipsos. / Heu miseri! fugiant longius mediocres a uobis. / Vixit et extinxit pauper t ebreica clames. / Mox furiis ageris, cum pereas ipse, Charybdis. / Indisciplinati sicut * * diuites estis: / Legem datis istis, nam uobis parcitis ipsis. / Exue te, diues, tantis malis Deo reuersus, / Subueniat [uti]que tibi, quod nunc operasti si forte. / Estote communes minimis, dum tempus habetis; / Sicut ulmus amat uitem, sic ipsi pusillos. / Terribilem legem malis bonis atque benignam / Obserua, nunc sterilis! subditus in prosperis esto: / Tollite corda fraudis, diuites, et sumite pacis. / Expiate malum uestrum benefactis a Summo.

You rich, be humble. Learn, you who must die, to show goodness to all. Why do you make yourself something apart in the midst of the people? You go where you do not know, and you go back from there unknowing. You deal impiously with your very body, thirsting after riches; you lift yourself too high … and you do not look to the poor who are now subject to us, nor do you even feed your own parents. Alas, you wretches! Let people of modest means flee far from you. … Soon the Furies will drive you, when you perish yourself, you Charybdis. You rich are undisciplined like … ; you lay down the law for these, but you spare yourselves. Strip yourself, rich man, of such great evils and turn back to God, so that what you have done now may perhaps help you. Be generous to the least while you have time; as the elm loves the vine, so love the little ones. Keep the law, terrible to the wicked and kind to the good, you who are now barren! Be submissive in prosperity. Put away hearts of fraud, you rich, and take up hearts of peace. Atone for your evil with good deeds before the Most High.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Gal 6:10 (echo, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Commodian rebukes the proud rich and urges them to share with the poor and atone for their sins by good deeds.

  • The acrostic spells DIVITES HVMILES ESTOTE. The lines “Et t stifam ducis” and “Vixit et extinxit pauper t ebreica clames” are corrupt and are marked “…”; the editor marks a gap (* *) and deletes “uti” in “[uti]que.”
  • “While you have time”: compare Gal 6:10. The elm and the vine is a common image (compare Hermas, Sim. 2).

Extrabiblical texts: Herm. Sim. 2 (Shepherd of Hermas: Similitudes; echo)

Topics: Ethics

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.30 (CSEL 15:40–41; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-30). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-30) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.

1.31CSEL 15:41–42

XXXI. IVDICIBVS. Intuite dicta Salomonis, iudices omnes, / Vno uerbo suo qualiter uos ille detractat: / Dona quam et xenia corrumpunt iudices omnes! / Idem: V (o)s, sequit 〈ut〉, datorem semper amatis; / Cum quaerit(ur), causa uictoriam tollit iniqua. / Innocens hic ego sum, nec uos incuso pusillus, / Blasphemium tollat Salomon, qui (clamat) aperte. / Vobis autem Deus est uenter et praemia iura. / Suggerit hoc Paulus apostolus, non ego pulex.

To judges. Look at the sayings of Solomon, all you judges, how with a single word he disparages you: “How gifts and presents corrupt all judges!” The same: “You follow and always love the giver; when the case is examined, the unjust side carries off the victory.” I am innocent here; I, a little one, do not accuse you; let Solomon bear the reproach, who (cries it) openly. But to you God is your belly, and bribes are law. The apostle Paul suggests this, not I, a flea.

Exod 23:8 (allusion, medium confidence) · Deut 16:19 (allusion, medium confidence) · Isa 1:23 (allusion, medium confidence) · Prov 17:23 (allusion, low confidence) · Phil 3:19 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Commodian reminds judges of Scripture's warnings against bribery.

  • The acrostic spells IVDICIBVS. The sayings ascribed to Solomon are loosely based on Exod 23:8, Deut 16:19, and Isa 1:23; the exact source is uncertain. “Whose god is the belly”: Phil 3:19. Words in brackets are the editor's supplements.

Topics: Ethics

Cite (SBL): Commodian, Instr. 1.31 (CSEL 15:41–42; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/commodian-instructiones/1/#p-1-31). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-commodian-instructiones-1-31) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin text of CSEL 15; made independently of existing English translations and compared afterwards with ANF where it has the work.